Creative Production Supervisor

Creative Production Supervisor

Lead creativity. Inspire innovation. Shape the future.

Location: Peoria, Illinois (On-site)

Do you thrive at the intersection of creative leadership, digital innovation, and hands-on design?

Illinois Mutual is searching for an experienced Creative Production Supervisor to lead a talented team of designers, web developers, videographers, and multimedia professionals while helping shape the future of our brand across every customer touchpoint.

This is not your typical creative management position. We're looking for a creative leader who is equally comfortable discussing UI/UX strategy, directing a video shoot, reviewing front-end code, mentoring designers, brainstorming marketing campaigns, improving website accessibility, or helping redefine how our brand comes to life digitally.

If you're passionate about developing people, solving creative challenges, and producing work that makes a lasting impact, we'd love to meet you.

About Illinois Mutual

For more than 115 years, Illinois Mutual has helped individuals and families protect their financial futures.

As a mutual insurance company, our focus has never been on shareholdersit has always been on people. We believe in doing what's right for our policyowners, our independent agents, our employees, and the communities we serve.

Today, we're investing heavily in digital experiences, creative storytelling, customer engagement, and marketing innovation. This position will play a key leadership role in that transformation.

What You'll Do

As Creative Production Supervisor, you'll serve as the creative leader for Illinois Mutual's Marketing Communications & Research team, overseeing a talented group of four creative professionals responsible for delivering high-quality experiences across print, digital, web, video, photography, social media, and emerging marketing technologies.

Lead an Incredible Creative Team

• Mentor, coach and develop a team of creative professionals
• Foster collaboration, innovation and continuous improvement
• Help each team member grow personally and professionally
• Build an environment where creativity and accountability thrive

Shape Our Creative Vision

• Lead the creative direction of Illinois Mutual's brand
• Guide the visual strategy across all marketing channels
• Ensure brand consistency across every customer's experience
• Partner with executive leadership on major initiatives and campaigns

Drive Digital Innovation

• Lead website strategy and front-end development initiatives
• Champion UI/UX best practices
• Guide accessibility efforts aligned with WCAG standards
• Collaborate closely with IT and digital teams on new experiences

Create Amazing Work

Oversee the development of:

• Websites and landing pages
• Digital campaigns
• Print advertising
• Video productions
• Photography
• Animation
• Email marketing
• Social media creative
• Annual Reports
• Presentations
• Trade show experiences
• Marketing collateral
• Branded experiences across every platform

Keep Big Projects Moving

Lead multiple high-profile initiatives simultaneously, including:

• Annual Report creative direction
• Website enhancements and SEO initiatives
• Agent Portal redesigns
• Video production
• Company-wide campaigns
• Executive presentations
• Digital marketing initiatives
• Vendor partnerships and creative production

Your work will directly influence many of the company's strategic marketing initiatives planned for 2026 and beyond, including website enhancements, digital experiences, annual reports, large-scale campaigns, video strategy, and brand modernization.

We're Looking For Someone Who...

We're seeking an experienced creative professional who combines artistic talent with strong leadership.

You should be someone who:

• Inspires and mentors creative professionals
• Leads with fairness, integrity and empathy
• Enjoys rolling up your sleeves and creating alongside your team
• Thinks strategically while executing tactically
• Loves solving creative problems
• Thrives in a collaborative environment
• Is passionate about design, technology and innovation
• Can balance multiple priorities without sacrificing quality
• Brings energy, curiosity and fresh ideas every day

Most importantly, you're someone who enjoys helping others succeed.

Anticipated Salary: $74,000 - $77,500

Benefits Overview: We strive for our employees to feel appreciated and supported, both professionally and personally. Our comprehensive benefit and discount package that meets a variety of needs is one way we demonstrate this. Some of our most admired benefits include:

• Compressed 4 1/2-day work week (Half-Day Fridays)
• No monthly premium cost for employee medical, life and disability insurance coverage
• Paid time-off accrual, including annual rollover; and paid holidays
• Competitive 401(k) plan with immediate vesting on Company contributions
• Discounted on-site employee cafeteria
• On-site exercise facility and company-provided exercise time
• Tuition reimbursement and training incentives
• Access to voluntary dental and vision insurance coverage

Qualifications

Required

• Bachelor's degree in Graphic Design, Web Design, Multimedia, Interactive Design, Fine Arts or related field
• 10+ years of professional creative experience
• 2+ years leading or supervising creative teams
• Strong online portfolio showcasing design and multimedia work
• Experience in graphic design, UI/UX, front-end development, video production and creative strategy
• Strong communication, collaboration and project leadership skills

Technical Experience

Experience with many of the following:

• HTML, CSS and JavaScript
• Content Management Systems (Sitefinity or similar)
• Adobe Creative Cloud (Photoshop, InDesign, Illustrator, Audition, After Effect, Premiere Pro, Acrobat, Firefly)
• Adobe Workfront
• Figma
• UI/UX Design
• Video production and editing
• Photography
• Google Analytics & Google Tag Manager
• Email marketing platforms
• WCAG accessibility
• AI-powered creative tools including ChatGPT
• Creative project management platforms
• Social media content creation
• Insurance or financial services experience is a plus.

Why Illinois Mutual?

You'll join an organization where creativity has a seat at the table.

You'll have the opportunity to:

• Lead meaningful creative work that reaches thousands of customers and independent agents
• Influence company-wide marketing strategy
• Mentor and develop an exceptional creative team
• Work on diverse projects across web, video, branding, UX, print and digital marketing
• Help modernize a respected 115-year-old brand
• Collaborate with executive leadership
• Continue growing your own creative and leadership skills

This Role Is Perfect For Someone Who Wants To...

Lead instead of simply manage

Mentor instead of micromanage

Create instead of just review

Innovate instead of maintain

Build a team instead of oversee one

Leave a lasting creative legacy

Ready to Help Shape the Future?

If you're an experienced creative leader who enjoys mentoring talented people, producing exceptional work, and helping transform a respected brand through creativity and innovation, we'd love to hear from you.

Apply today and bring your creativity to Illinois Mutual.

This job description is intended to