Talent.com
Rustman Agency
Customer Retention Sales ManagerRustman Agency • Madison, WI, United States
Customer Retention Sales Manager

Customer Retention Sales Manager

Rustman Agency • Madison, WI, United States
3 days ago
Job type
  • Full-time
Job description

Customer Retention Sales Manager

The Rustman Agency is a fast-growing brokerage focused on helping families protect their financial futures. We provide life insurance, final expense, and mortgage protection solutions with a strong emphasis on integrity, service, and long-term client relationships.

We are seeking a Customer Retention Sales Manager to lead our client loyalty efforts. In this role, you will manage a team focused on maintaining and growing relationships with existing clients. You will help ensure policyholders stay engaged, supported, and protected. This position is ideal for a relationship-driven leader who thrives on service, strategy, and performance.

Manage a remote team dedicated to customer retention and satisfaction

Develop and implement strategies to reduce policy cancellations

Support existing clients through policy reviews and value-based conversations

Identify upsell opportunities where appropriate

Handle escalated concerns with professionalism and care

Track team performance and provide coaching to improve results

Work closely with sales and service teams to ensure continuity in the customer journey

Maintain accurate records of communication and performance

Remote work with flexible hours

Leadership bonuses and uncapped commission potential

Ongoing training and development

Supportive team culture focused on impact and growth

Clear advancement opportunities in a growing agency

Minimum of two years of experience in sales, customer service, or account management

Previous leadership or management experience preferred

Background in insurance or financial services is a plus

Strong communication, problem-solving, and organizational skills

Comfortable using CRM platforms and managing remote workflows

Life and Health insurance license or willingness to obtain within 30 days

Create a job alert for this search

Customer Retention Sales Manager • Madison, WI, United States

Similar jobs

Sales Manager

Park Lawn CorporationSun Prairie, WI, United States
Full-time +1

Why Work for Cress Funeral Home & Wichmann Funeral Home? Service At every level, our dedicated team members display a strong work ethic and commitment to our core values, respect for the family, th... Show more

 • Promoted

Hybrid Coach and Sales Manager

KidstrongSun Prairie, WI, United States
Full-time

Sales Manager Position At KidStrong Sun Prairie.KidStrong is a science-based kids training program that builds strong, confident and high-character kids.Kids walking to age 11 tackle challenges in ... Show more

 • Promoted

Job Coach

TradeJobsWorkForce53502 Albany, WI, US
Full-time

Developing and implementing effective coaching strategies to help clients overcome employment-related challenges.Identifying clients' strengths and advising them on how to use those strengths to se... Show more

 • Promoted

Traveling Sales Manager

Milan LaserMadison, WI, United States
Full-time

Based out of: Madison, WI Candidates must reside within close proximity to a major airport.At Milan Laser Hair Removal, every clinic you support is an opportunity to transform lives; helping client... Show more

 • Promoted

Remote Product Tester - Flexible Studies

BuzzTestersEvansville, WI
Remote
Full-time

Earn up to $400/week, depending on the number and type of studies you complete.Share honest feedback on products and services from independent brands.Assignments include short online surveys (10–20... Show more

 • Promoted

Sales Consultant

Victra - Verizon Wireless Premium RetailerSun Prairie, WI, US
$40,000.00 yearly
Full-time

Victra is Verizon's largest premium retailer in the United States.We are seeking Sales Consultants who deliver world-class service to Every Guest.From executing Victra's sales process to sharing yo... Show more

Customer Service Rep (100% Work From Home)

WayfairSun Prairie, WI, United States
Remote
Full-time

Like any home, what's inside Wayfair's home is special.Wayfair is home to great people, great ideas and possibly YOU! Customer Service Reps @ Wayfair: Provide best in class customer experience to r... Show more

 • Promoted

Customer Retention Sales Manager

Rustman AgencyMadison, WI, United States
Full-time

Customer Retention Sales Manager.The Rustman Agency is a fast-growing brokerage focused on helping families protect their financial futures.We provide life insurance, final expense, and mortgage pr... Show more

 • Promoted

Regional Sales Manager (Midwest Territory) - Remote

Insight GlobalSun Prairie, WI, United States
Remote
Full-time

Midwest-based Regional Sales Manager.PAE is seeking a Midwest-based Regional Sales Manager to develop and expand strategic manufacturing relationships across the region.This individual will lead bu... Show more

 • Promoted

Outbound Sales Agent - (Commission Based - 12-month contract - Fully Remote)

WebafricaDe Forest, WI, United States
Remote
Temporary

Job TitleWebafrica is on the prowl for a super savvy Outbound Sales Agent to join the team.If you are a spunky go-getter who's a little left-of-centre, totally customer orientated and your sales ga... Show more

 • Promoted

ENTRY LEVEL SALES - 40k BASE

SpectrumFootville, WI, United States
Full-time

Average Target Compensation of $105,000 Uncapped Incentives JOB SUMMARYConnect people and communities by offering best-in-class telecommunication services through door-to-door solicitation of new p... Show more

 • Promoted

Sales and Operations Management Trainee

PenskeWindsor, WI, United States
Full-time

Sales And Operations Management Trainee.Exciting entry-level opportunity for those who have obtained their bachelor's degree!.As a Sales and Operations Management Trainee in our fast-paced environm... Show more

 • Promoted

County Meter Reader

Meter ReaderBrodhead, WI
Full-time

Responsibilities The primary responsibility of this position is to read meters and record consumption of the water used, cleaning of meter boxes, and removal of vegetation impeding access to meters... Show more

 • Promoted

Sales Consultant, Home Remodeling

WAUNAKEE REMODELINGWaunakee, WI, United States
Full-time

About Us At Waunakee Remodeling, we're not just transforming homes--we're creating spaces where memories are made and dreams come true.As a leader in our industry, we take pride in our craftsmanshi... Show more

 • Promoted

Licensed Insurance Sales Representative - P&C (Remote)

CONNECT, powered by American Family InsuranceSun Prairie, WI, United States
Remote
Full-time

This position is responsible for quoting and selling insurance policy premiums to incoming sales prospects from advertising ad purchased leads while providing excellent customer service to new and ... Show more

 • Promoted

e-COMMERCE/DEPARTMENT LEAD

KrogerSun Prairie, WI, United States
Full-time

Assist the Store e-Commerce manager in managing the day-to-day operation of the store's e-Commerce department.Demonstrate the company's core values of respect, honesty, integrity, diversity, inclus... Show more

 • Promoted

Salon Manager

Cost CuttersSun Prairie, WI, United States
Full-time

If you're looking for an opportunity to unleash your potential as a leader and salon manager, you've come to the right place.Leading with style, kindness, compassion, and care puts you a cut above ... Show more

 • Promoted

Salon Manager

Regis CorporationSun Prairie, WI, United States
Full-time

If you're looking for an opportunity to unleash your potential as a leader and salon manager, you've come to the right place.Leading with style, kindness, compassion, and care puts you a cut above ... Show more

 • Promoted

Care Manager, LTSS (RN) - Field travel in Dane County, WI

Molina HealthcareWaunakee, WI, United States
Full-time

Sign on bonus available for eligible candidates Remote with field travel in Dane County JOB DESCRIPTIONJob SummaryProvides support for care management/care coordination long-term services and supp... Show more

 • Promoted

Outside Parts Sales Executive

JX EnterprisesDe Forest, WI, United States
Full-time

Job TypeFull-timeDescriptionAbout Us:At JX, we are more than just a provider in the diesel industry; we are a team united by core values that define our commitment to excellence.Our employees play ... Show more